Getting a Counter Offer From Your Current Employer and How to Price It Against the New Job
What are you negotiating?
Your offer or current pay
Market-rate band
Talking points
Email template
Timing
Coaching, not legal or financial advice.
Getting a counter offer from your current employer is the moment your old job becomes a competing offer, and it should be priced like one. Put the new job and the counter side by side on base, bonus target, equity that vests in the next 12 months, retirement match and the cost of anything you would give up, then compare the totals for the first year. If the counter wins on the numbers and fixes the reason you were leaving, it is a real option. If it only matches on base and leaves the rest open, ask for the missing lines in writing before you answer. This is career coaching, not legal or financial advice.
Step one: turn both offers into one comparable year
People compare a salary to a salary and miss the lines that differ. Build the first-year total for each side. For the new job use the offer letter. For the counter, use only what is written down, since a verbal "we will take care of you" has no number to price. Our total compensation calculator adds base, bonus, equity and benefits into one figure so the comparison is not done in your head.
A worked example with the lines people forget
The figures below are hypothetical and rounded. They show how a counter that looks equal on base can still trail the new job by tens of thousands in the first year.
| Line | New job offer | Counter from current employer |
|---|---|---|
| Base salary | $132,000 | $130,000 |
| Annual bonus at target | $13,200 (10 percent) | $6,500 (5 percent) |
| Equity vesting in year one | $18,000 | $6,000 (existing grant, no new grant) |
| Sign-on or retention bonus | $15,000 | $10,000 (paid in 12 months) |
| Retirement match | $5,280 (4 percent) | $3,900 (3 percent) |
| First-year total | $183,480 | $156,400 |
On base alone the gap is $2,000 and the counter looks close. Add the lines and the gap is $27,080, which is the real question: does staying cost that much, and what are you buying with it? Our employer counteroffer page works through this with your own figures.
What to check in the counter before you answer
- Is it a raise or a one-time payment? A $10,000 retention bonus is paid once and can come with repayment terms. A $10,000 raise repeats and compounds into every future raise. Ask which one it is, and see the retention bonus guide for the repayment clauses to read.
- Does it change the role, level or reporting line? If the reason you looked was the work or the manager, a number alone does not touch it. A new title, scope or reporting line in writing does.
- Is there a date on the next review? A counter that promises a raise "at the next cycle" is a promise, not an offer. Ask for the cycle date and the target in writing.
- What happens to your equity? A new grant resets the vesting clock, which can lock you in for four years. Check whether the counter adds unvested equity or only restates what you already own.
Should you accept the counter offer?
Accept only when the written counter beats the new job on total pay or on the thing that made you look, and when you are comfortable with how it was reached. Some employers raise pay only after a resignation, which tells you how future raises will go. For the wider decision about leaving or staying, read should you accept a counteroffer, and for the pattern behind the numbers see counteroffer statistics.
How to reply to the counter in writing
Do not accept in the meeting. Ask for the terms in an email and give yourself a day. If you want to counter your employer's counter, name the one line that decides it. In the example above that is the bonus and the new grant, not the base. Keep it short and warm.
Subject: Thank you for the offer to stay
Hi [Name], thank you for taking this seriously and for the offer. Before I decide, could you send the terms in writing, including the base, the bonus target and the new equity grant? The other role includes [$X] in first-year bonus and equity, so a package closer to [$Y] total would make staying a clear choice. I can confirm by [date].
If the counter comes back with real movement on the line that matters and a written role change, that is a result worth taking. If it comes back as base only, you have your answer. For the counter-the-counter wording, our negotiation scripts cover tone and follow-up, and an outside source like the BLS Occupational Outlook Handbook can anchor the market pay for your role.
When the numbers are close, price the non-money terms
If the first-year totals land within a few thousand dollars, the decision moves to terms that have no line in the table. Commute or remote days, the team you will work with, the manager you will report to, and how fast the next promotion can realistically arrive all change what the same pay feels like. Give each a rough weight, then ask whether the counter changes any of them. If it changes none, the new job is buying you something the old one is not, and the money gap should be larger than the table shows before staying makes sense.
Also price the cost of the switch. Leaving costs you unvested equity, an unpaid bonus and sometimes a repayment of an old sign-on. Our sign-on bonus repayment calculator sizes what you may owe, and the new employer can often cover it if you ask before you sign. A switch that is worth $27,000 in the first year on paper may be worth $15,000 after what you forfeit, which still might be enough, but it should be a number you chose and not a surprise.
After you decide
If you stay, get the agreed terms in a signed letter or an updated compensation record and put the next review date on your calendar. If you leave, thank your manager plainly and keep the handover clean. Either way you now hold a real market data point, which is worth keeping for the next conversation about pay.
The takeaway
A counter offer from your current employer is only as good as its written total against the new job over the first year, plus whether it fixes the reason you looked. Counteroffer turns both offers into one comparison and drafts the reply. These figures are examples and this is coaching, not legal or financial advice. Price your counter offer in minutes.
Build your counteroffer with Counteroffer.
Paste your offer or current pay and get a market-rate band, the number to counter with, talking points, and an email template, in minutes.
Keep reading