Executive Compensation Negotiation for Your Executive Salary and Compensation Package
An executive offer is five or six separate numbers, and the company usually opens strongest on the one that matters least: base. Counteroffer reads your offer, prices the target bonus, the equity grant and the awards you forfeit, and drafts the counter email that asks for the right lever first.
Coaching, not legal or financial advice.
What are you negotiating?
Your offer or current pay
Market-rate band
Talking points
Email template
Timing
Coaching, not legal or financial advice.
Direct answer
Executive compensation negotiation works best when you negotiate the package in the order that moves the most money: the long-term equity grant, the make-whole for awards you forfeit by leaving, the target bonus percentage, then base salary, then severance and change in control terms. Base sits inside a band the compensation committee has already approved, while the grant size, a sign-on or replacement award and a guaranteed first-year bonus are one-time decisions with far more room. Put every number in one written counter, tie each ask to evidence such as an unvested award statement or a competing offer, and get the final terms in the employment agreement. This is career coaching, not legal advice.
Run the numbers
Size the make-whole before you name a number.
Most executives leave real money behind when they move: the bonus they will not be there to collect, the equity that would have vested in the next year, an unvested retirement match, and sometimes a clawback they owe. Enter those figures and the calculator returns the gross sign-on or cash buyout that replaces them after tax. That figure is the floor of your make-whole ask, and it is the line most executive offers underprice. Nothing you type is uploaded or stored.
Sign on bonus calculator
2026 federal brackets, Social Security and Medicare
What you give up by leaving your current job
Sign-on bonus that makes you whole
gross, to replace you lose by leaving, after tax.
What the offered sign-on really nets
- Sign-on bonus (gross)
- Withheld at the flat 22 percent (settles when you file)
- Federal tax it really causes at your bracket
- Social Security and Medicare
- State income tax
- What you actually keep
A sign-on bonus is supplemental wages. Employers withhold federal tax at a flat 22 percent, 37 percent on the part above $1 million in a year (IRS Publication 15). Brackets from Rev. Proc. 2025-32, state tax applied as a flat rate, forfeited pay valued at your new salary. This is career coaching, not tax advice.
The problem
The offer arrives from a search partner or the CEO with a base salary that looks generous, a bonus described as a percentage of base, and an equity line written as a share count with no dollar value. Meanwhile the executive is walking away from an unvested grant and a bonus that pays out three months after the start date. Agree to the base on the call, and the make-whole, the grant and the severance are now being negotiated by someone who has already said yes.
How Counteroffer handles it
Paste the offer letter, the term sheet or the draft agreement, plus your current unvested award statement. Counteroffer puts a dollar value on every line, works out what you forfeit by leaving and what replaces it after tax, compares the target bonus and grant against the ranges you supply, and drafts one counter email that asks for the make-whole and the grant before base. It does not invent market data. It uses the figures you paste in, including peer pay you read from public proxy statements, and names every anchor it used. For the contract itself, retain an employment attorney as well.
The numbers
What moves in an executive compensation package and what rarely does.
Public companies disclose how they pay their named executive officers in the proxy statement, which makes the Summary Compensation Table the best free benchmark for a senior role. Use the table below as the order of questions to ask, not as a promise that any line will move.
| Package line | How it is usually set | Room to negotiate | What to ask for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Long-term equity grant | A dollar value set at hire, converted to shares or units on a grant date, vesting over three or four years | High. A one-time decision, often the largest number in the package | A grant value in dollars, the grant date, and the vesting and performance conditions in writing |
| Make-whole or replacement award | Cash or equity that replaces unvested awards and bonus you forfeit by leaving | High, when you document what you forfeit | A replacement award matched to your unvested statement, on a similar vesting schedule |
| Sign-on bonus | One-time cash, usually with a repayment clause if you leave within one or two years | High | The amount plus a pro-rated repayment clause that falls away on termination without cause |
| Target annual bonus | A percentage of base set by level, paid against company and individual goals | Moderate. The percentage is tied to level, the first-year payout is easier | A higher target percentage or a guaranteed, non-prorated first-year bonus |
| Base salary | Set within a band the board or committee approved for the role | Low to moderate | A figure near the top of the band, with a written review date |
| Severance and change in control | Months of base and bonus paid on termination without cause or for good reason | Moderate, and it costs the company nothing on day one | A defined multiple, a good reason clause, and double-trigger equity acceleration |
| Perquisites and benefits | Car, financial planning, executive physical, deferred compensation, supplemental life insurance | Moderate. Small cost, often already in a policy | Whatever the company already gives peer executives, confirmed by the policy document |
Grant practices, bands and perquisite policies are set by each company and its compensation committee. Read the latest proxy statement on SEC EDGAR to see what the company actually paid executives at your level, then confirm every term in the agreement.
How to do it
How to negotiate executive compensation, step by step.
Do not agree to a number on the call
Thank the CEO or search partner, say you are excited about the role, and ask for the full package in writing: base, target bonus percentage, grant value in dollars, vesting, sign-on, severance and benefits. Agreeing to base out loud turns every other line into a favor rather than a term.
Price what you are walking away from
Pull your unvested award statement and list what vests in the next 12 to 24 months, the bonus you would have been paid for this year, any unvested retirement match, and any repayment you owe your current employer. That total is the make-whole. Our sign-on bonus calculator converts it into the gross figure that replaces it after tax.
Read the proxy for peer pay
If the company is public, its proxy statement lists base, bonus, stock awards and all other compensation for its top executives, and the Compensation Discussion and Analysis explains the target bonus percentages and the peer group. You can search filings for free on SEC EDGAR full-text search. A private company has no proxy, so ask the search partner for the band and the grant range.
Ask for the grant and the make-whole before base
Lead with the long-term grant in dollars and the replacement award for what you forfeit, because both are one-time decisions with the most room. Then ask for the target bonus percentage or a guaranteed first-year bonus. Raise base last, as the item you are willing to trade. For grant mechanics, see how to negotiate equity, RSUs and vesting.
Clarify scope and the resources that come with it
Ask for the team, the budget and the reporting line in writing, since your bonus will be measured against goals that depend on them. A chief marketing officer, for example, should ask what already works before committing to a pipeline target: whether new pages even reach Google search on time, a problem tools like Indexing exist to fix, changes how fast any plan can deliver.
Settle the exit terms before you sign
Severance, good reason and change in control protection cost the company nothing on the day you join, which is why they are easier to win now than at any later point. The executive employment agreement guide prices each clause, and the executive severance package calculator tests the multiple you were offered. If a deal could trigger the golden parachute rules, read our 280G calculation example before you agree to a gross-up or a cutback.
Send one written counter and get it into the agreement
Put every ask in one email with the evidence behind it and a date for your answer. Once the company agrees, check that the employment agreement, the grant agreement and the plan document all say the same thing, because the plan document wins where they differ. The perks are a separate, shorter list, covered in executive perks to negotiate.
copy and paste
The executive compensation counter email.
Send this to the CEO, the head of people or the search partner after the written offer. It leads with the make-whole and the grant, names the evidence, and leaves base as the item you can trade.
Subject: [Role] offer, proposed package Hi [Name], Thank you for the offer. I am excited about [the mandate] and want to get to a yes quickly. Two items matter most to me. First, by leaving [current company] in [month] I forfeit [figure] of unvested equity and a [figure] bonus for this year, documented in the attached statement. I would like a replacement award of [figure] on a vesting schedule similar to the one I give up. Second, I would like the long-term grant set at [figure] in grant value, which is in line with what [peer roles or the latest proxy] show for this level. I would also like the target bonus at [percentage] with the first year guaranteed and not prorated, and severance of [months] of base plus target bonus on a termination without cause or for good reason. If we agree on those, I am comfortable with the base as offered. I can give you a final answer by [date]. Best, [Your name]
Swap the bracketed parts for your own numbers. Counteroffer writes this for your exact offer.
Frequently asked
Executive compensation negotiation questions people actually ask.
How do you negotiate executive compensation?
Ask for the full package in writing, price the equity and bonus you forfeit by leaving, then counter in one email that leads with the long-term grant and a make-whole award, followed by the target bonus, base and severance. Tie each ask to evidence such as an unvested award statement, a competing offer or published proxy pay.
What is negotiable in an executive compensation package?
Almost every line, but not equally. The long-term equity grant, the replacement award for forfeited equity, the sign-on bonus and a guaranteed first-year bonus usually have the most room. Base salary and the target bonus percentage are tied to an approved band and move less. Severance and perquisites are negotiable and cheap for the company to grant at hire.
Should executives negotiate base salary or equity?
Equity first in most cases. Base sits inside a band the compensation committee has approved, while the grant value is a one-time decision with more room and a larger effect on four-year pay. Base still matters because the target bonus and often the severance are calculated from it, so raise it last as the item you can trade.
What is a make-whole award?
A make-whole, or replacement award, is cash or equity a new employer grants to replace unvested equity and bonus you forfeit by leaving your current job. It is usually sized from your unvested award statement and vests on a schedule similar to the one you give up. Ask for it explicitly, because it is rarely offered in full by default.
How much can you negotiate on an executive offer?
It depends on what you forfeit, the company stage and how many candidates remain. The make-whole can be negotiated close to the documented value of what you leave behind, since it is evidence based. Base usually moves a few percent within the band. The grant moves most when you have a competing offer or a strong peer benchmark.
Do executives need a lawyer to negotiate compensation?
For a senior offer, an employment attorney should review the agreement, the grant agreement and the plan documents before you sign, especially the severance, good reason, change in control and restrictive covenant clauses. Many companies reimburse legal fees for executive hires up to a cap, so ask for that in the counter as well.
Sources
- SEC EDGAR full-text search for proxy statements
- Regulation S-K Item 402, executive compensation disclosure
Figures are estimates and market data changes; verify anything you plan to quote in a negotiation.
What it uses
The features behind executive compensation negotiation.
More use cases
Walk in knowing your number.
Counteroffer is educational career coaching, not legal, financial, or HR advice.