Counteroffer

Contract to Hire vs Full Time Pay and the Worked Math Behind the Hourly Rate

Devin Park, Compensation··7 min read
Strategy builder

What are you negotiating?

Your offer or current pay

Market-rate band

Their offer Your counter

Talking points

Email template

Timing

Coaching, not legal or financial advice.

Adjust: rebuilt ✓

Contract to hire vs full time is a comparison most people make on the hourly rate alone, and that is the mistake. A contractor paid by the hour gets no paid days off, usually no employer benefits and no bonus, so a rate that looks 10 percent higher can pay less over a year than a lower salary. Price both as a full-year total, then settle the conversion salary, date and agency fee before you accept. The contract to hire salary negotiation page walks through the negotiation itself.

Why the conversion terms matter more than the hourly rate

The hourly rate lasts a few months. The conversion salary becomes your base for every raise after it. A contract to hire role usually runs through a staffing agency, which sets your hourly pay from the bill rate it charges the client, and the client then pays a conversion fee or waits out a period before hiring you directly. Our bill rate vs pay rate calculator shows how much of the bill rate you actually receive, which tells you how much room the agency has to move.

The conversion fee is the lever people forget. If the client must pay the agency a large fee to hire you early, they may stall the conversion, so ask when the fee drops or disappears (often after a set number of hours or months) and get that date in the contract.

A worked example of contract pay against the salary you convert to

The figures are hypothetical and rounded, using a 2,080 hour year. They show why an hourly rate that looks generous can trail a lower salary once benefits and paid time off are priced.

LineContract phase (W-2 through agency)Converted full-time role
Pay$55 an hour, about $114,400 if worked all year$105,000 salary
Paid time offNone, unpaid when you do not work15 days paid, already inside the salary
Paid holidaysNone, unpaid9 days paid, already inside the salary
Health plan employer shareAgency plan, often costs more to youAbout $7,000 employer contribution
Retirement matchUsually none4 percent, $4,200
Bonus at targetNone5 percent, $5,250
Comparable annual valueAbout $103,800 after 24 unpaid days (24 x 8 x $55 = $10,560)About $121,450 (salary plus health, match and bonus)

On the hourly line the contract looks higher by about $9,400. Once you subtract the unpaid days and add the lines that only the salaried role carries, the conversion salary wins by roughly $17,600. That is the reason to negotiate the conversion number now, while the client wants to keep you, rather than after you have been absorbed into their pay scale. The total compensation calculator prices these lines for your own numbers.

What to ask for before you sign the contract

  • The conversion salary or range. Ask the hiring manager, not the agency, what the role is budgeted at. If they will not name a number, ask for the band. A contract that says only "eligible for conversion" is not a promise.
  • The earliest conversion date. Typical windows run from three to twelve months, but they vary. Ask for the date or the hours threshold that ends the agency fee, and get it in the offer or an email from the client.
  • Credit for time served. Ask that your contract months count toward tenure for paid time off accrual, vesting and the first review. Without it you restart the clock on day one of the conversion.
  • Benefits start date. Confirm whether benefits begin on the conversion date or after a waiting period, and whether a waiting period would leave you uninsured.
  • The bonus and equity eligibility. Ask whether the first-year bonus is prorated from conversion or from the contract start, and whether equity is part of the converted package.

W-2 contractor or 1099 contractor, and why it changes the math

If the agency pays you as a W-2 employee, taxes are withheld and the agency covers the employer share. If you are paid as a 1099 contractor, you pay both halves of self-employment tax and buy your own benefits, which can swallow a large share of the premium rate. Our 1099 vs W-2 calculator converts a 1099 rate into a comparable salary. The IRS explains the legal test for independent contractor vs employee status, which matters if the client controls how and when you work.

Should you negotiate the hourly rate too?

Yes, but with a different goal. The hourly rate matters most if the role may not convert, since it is your whole pay. Ask the agency for a rate that covers your unpaid time off and benefits, and use the bill rate difference as a guide for how much room exists. Do not trade a higher conversion salary for a slightly higher hourly rate. The salary compounds, and the hourly rate ends the day you convert.

If you want to reach the hiring manager directly and learn the real budget, a short note works better than going through the recruiter alone. Some people use cold email software that finds decision makers when the hiring manager is hard to identify, but a simple LinkedIn message works for most roles.

The email to send before you accept

Send this to the recruiter and copy the hiring manager if you have been introduced. Keep it warm and specific.

Subject: A few details on the conversion terms

Hi [Name], thank you for the offer. I am excited about the role and the team. Before I accept, could you confirm in writing the conversion salary or band, the earliest date the role can convert and how the agency fee affects that date? I would also like my contract months to count toward paid time off accrual and the first review. If the conversion salary is near [$X], I can accept at the proposed hourly rate. I can confirm by [date].

What to do if the answer is vague

If nobody will name a conversion number, treat the role as a contract and price it that way. Ask for a higher hourly rate that covers your risk, keep looking in parallel and set your own review date, such as 90 days, after which you will decide. Employers who value you will usually put something in writing once you show you are weighing the offer carefully. Our counter offer builder helps you set the number and the wording when the terms are unclear.

After the conversion offer arrives

When the full-time offer comes, treat it like any other: compare total pay, not only base, and negotiate again if the figure is lower than what you were told. The same rules apply, and our internal job offer negotiation guide covers moving to a new pay band inside the same company, which is close to what a conversion is. Because you already know the team, you can point to specific results in the contract period as evidence for placement at the upper half of the band.

The takeaway

Contract to hire salary negotiation is won on the conversion terms: the salary or band, the date, the fee and the credit for time served. Counteroffer prices the hourly role against the full-time offer and drafts the email. These figures are examples, and this is coaching, not legal or financial advice. Price your conversion offer in minutes.

Build your counteroffer with Counteroffer.

Paste your offer or current pay and get a market-rate band, the number to counter with, talking points, and an email template, in minutes.

See how it works

Counter your offer with confidence.